Give your opinions on Pre Katrina schools vs. Post Katrina schools. Giving the year 2004 vs 2010 what bands would dominate each other in a parade lineup???
2004 Aug vs. 2010 St. Aug
O. P. Walker v. Walker
Carver "U" v. Carver
McM v. McMain
Reed v Sarah T. Reed
McDonough 35 v 35
Warren Easton v. Easton
Joseph S. Clark v. Clark
Edna Karr v. Karr
Walter L. Cohen v Cohen
Replies
Pre Katrina's Cohen would smash Reed, Carver and Clark Right now ..lol
04-05 St. Aug vs. 09-10 St.Aug - This year's band impressed me, but they wouldn't have lasted against my senior year band
04-05 Reed vs. 09-10 Reed - 04-05 Reed and I don't think I need to explain why I picked 04-05 Reed to win
04-05 Carver vs. 09-10 Carver - 04-05. Carver was alright this past year, but again, I dont think I need to explain why I picked 04-05 Carver
04-05 McD #35 vs. 09-10 McD # 35 - 04-05. 04-05 McD # 35 was real good for football season but kinda fell off for parade season. They would still get 09-10 35 because they sounded better tho
04-05 Easton vs. 09-10 Easton - I think 04-05. Another situation of this year Easton being good, but not good enough. 04-05 Easton sounded better and was louder. They would have blew out Brooks' Easton bands too in my opinion and I marched for Brook @ Marshall (c/o 2001)
09-10 Walker vs. 04-05 Walker - 04-05 Walker was louder, but 09-10 Walker got a better sound and they got some heat, that's why I would pick them''
09-10 McMain vs. 04-05 McMain - 04-05 McMain sounded way better and was way more technical, but 09-10 McMain was good too, so that would be a toss up of preference,but I would go with 09-10 in a marching band battle.
09-10 Cohen vs. 04-05 Cohen - 09-10. They got a nice sound quality and they had tha same volume as 04-05 Cohen and they sounded better
09-10 Karr vs. 04-05 Karr -. I would go with 04-05. Every Pre-Katrina Karr band was good as far as technicallity and would go off at LMEA (like McMain) but unlike McMain, they were NOT built for marching band in my opinion. They NEVER impressed me
04-05 Clark vs. 09-10 Clark - 04-05. They was probably tha best kept secret in New Orleans that year besides Landry
03-04 St. Aug vs. 09-10 St.Aug - 03-04. Might have been a LIL more entertaining but 03-04 would have still won
03-04 Reed vs. 09-10 Reed - 03-04
03-04 Carver vs. 09-10 Carver - 03-04. They would have smashed 09-10 too.
03-04 McD #35 vs. 09-10 McD # 35 - 03-04 was the best band McD #35 had since Mr.Jones left (besides the 04-05 football season)
03-04 Easton vs. 09-10 Easton - I think 09-10 would win this one
09-10 Walker vs. 03-04 Walker - 03-04 Walker would smash 09-10. They had a few bad performances, but they still would have smashed this year's band
09-10 McMain vs. 03-04 McMain - I think 03-04 McMain would do 09-10. 03-04 was a lil less powerful, but sounded better.
09-10 Cohen vs. 03-04 Cohen - 09-10. 03-04 Cohen wasn't that bad, but they still woulda lost
09-10 Karr vs. 03-04 Karr - I would go with 09-10 again for tha same reason I picked them over 04-05.
03-04 Clark vs. 09-10 Clark - I don't remember 03-04 Clark that good, but I'ma go out on limb and say they would smash this year's Clark cuz they was sad.